"Lightning never strikes the same place twice." It is one of the most repeated sayings about the weather, and it is completely false. Lightning strikes the same place again and again, and some places are hit dozens of times every year. The myth survives because it sounds like common sense. The facts say the opposite.
The myth
The saying suggests that once lightning has hit a spot, that spot is somehow used up, as if nature keeps a tally and moves on. Nothing in the physics of lightning works that way. Every strike is an independent event. A place that was struck once is, if anything, more likely to be struck again, because whatever made it a good target the first time is still there.
What the record shows
The National Weather Service lists "lightning never strikes the same place twice" as a myth, and the numbers settle it. The Empire State Building in New York is struck by lightning an average of 23 times a year, according to the National Weather Service, and New York City Emergency Management puts the figure at about 25. In a single storm, the building was hit eight times in 24 minutes.
Toronto's CN Tower tells the same story. The 553-metre tower takes about 75 strikes a year by the operators' count. When researchers counted flashes optically over many seasons, the long-run average came out closer to 36 a year. On the night of 24 August 2011, cameras recorded 52 flashes hitting the tower in a little over 84 minutes, roughly one every 99 seconds.
Even a single strike hits the same spot more than once. What looks like one bolt is usually several discharges running down the same ionised channel a few hundredths of a second apart, which is why lightning flickers. NOAA's National Severe Storms Laboratory notes that a negative cloud-to-ground flash can contain as many as 20 return strokes. One strike, by the plain meaning of the word, has already hit the same spot many times before the thunder arrives.
Why some places get hit again and again
Lightning follows the path of least resistance to the ground, and that path depends on height, shape and isolation. Tall, pointed, isolated objects are the easiest targets, which is why skyscrapers, radio towers and lone trees in open fields get hit far more often than a house in a suburban block.
Above about 100 metres, tall structures can even launch their own leader upward into the storm, a discharge that begins at ground level and climbs. Researchers at the South Dakota School of Mines and Technology documented 81 upward flashes from ten towers in Rapid City between 2004 and 2010.
That is also why lightning rods work. A rod is designed to be struck again and again, giving the charge a safe path to the ground so the building itself is not damaged. If lightning truly never struck twice, a lightning rod would be useless after its first hit.
The safety facts that matter
- Lightning can strike more than three miles from the centre of a storm, with documented cases 10 to 15 miles away, sometimes under a clear blue sky. The National Weather Service rule is simple: if you can hear thunder, you are close enough to be struck. - Rubber tyres and rubber-soled shoes give no protection. A lightning strike carries hundreds of millions of volts, which a few millimetres of rubber cannot stop. A hard-topped car is safe because of its metal shell, not its tyres. - It is completely safe to touch a lightning strike victim. The human body does not store an electrical charge. - Crouching outdoors does not reduce your risk. The National Weather Service stopped recommending it in 2008. A lone tree is one of the worst places to shelter, since lightning prefers tall isolated objects and a strike can travel down the trunk and outward through the ground.
The verdict
The myth is false. Lightning strikes the same place repeatedly, and the taller and more isolated the target, the more often it happens. The Empire State Building alone is proof: it is hit around two dozen times a year, sometimes eight times in a single storm.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often is the Empire State Building struck by lightning?
About 23 times a year on average, according to the National Weather Service. In one storm it was hit eight times in 24 minutes.
Can lightning strike under a clear blue sky?
Yes. Bolts have been recorded 10 to 15 miles from the parent storm, well outside the rain. If you can hear thunder, you are close enough to be struck.
Is it safe to touch someone who has been struck by lightning?
Yes. The human body does not store an electrical charge, so a lightning strike victim is safe to touch and needs first aid at once.
Read More: Myths and Facts: Coffee Does Not Dehydrate You, Studies Show
Read More: Myths and Facts: Cracking Your Knuckles Does Not Cause Arthritis
Read More: Myths and Facts: Sugar Does Not Make Children Hyperactive
Read More: Myths and Facts: We Use All of Our Brain, Not Just 10 Percent




Comments
Be the first to comment on this story.